Question:
why is it that some english letters are silent when you pronounce them, like E in the name joel, T in the word
lc
2007-05-03 04:40:13 UTC
Restaurant both the first T and the second T are silent when you pronouce them. Please why is it like that
Eleven answers:
anonymous
2007-05-03 04:42:38 UTC
Why do you call the chair "chair"?
anonymous
2007-05-03 12:08:19 UTC
Why do you think English is one of the hardest languages to learn!



Mind you, it is the pronunciation and spelling that is difficult - and I sometimes wonder what people learn at school!



I do like the long answer, though.



Oh, and there is a good song by a chap called Tom Lehrer called 'silent E' which explains how the 'e' works - although he was an excellent satirical songwriter, he also wrote for Sesame Street:



Who can turn a can into a cane?

Who can turn a pan into a pane?

It's not too hard to see

It's silent e



Who can turn a cub into a cube?

Who can turn a tub into a tube?

It's elementary

For silent e



He took a pin and turned it into pine

He took a twin and turned him into twine



Who can turn a cap into a cape?

Who can turn a tap into a tape?

A little glob becomes a globe instantly

If you just add silent e



He turned a dam - alikazam! - into a dame

But my friend sam stayed just the same



Who can turn a man into a mane?

Who can turn a van into a vane?

A little hug becomes huge instantly

Don't add w, don't add x, and don't add y or z,

Just add silent e
anonymous
2007-05-03 23:20:05 UTC
I don't understand your comment about "restaurant" - though it's a French word, both "t"s are pronounced in English.



To get back to your question, the spelling for many of the words in our language was laid down and formalised before the pronunciation changed. For example, long ago every letter in the word "knight" was pronounced.



It's not restricted to English - the final "t" in "restaurant" (for example) is dropped in French, unless followed by a vowel, but long ago it was always pronounced. Compare the "w" in "law and order", and the "r" in "pepper and salt".
Bethany
2007-05-03 12:16:14 UTC
What you say is generally true. However, most languages are littered with redundant spellings. The Ts in restaurant are pronounced. I think Joel might come from Joelle, which needs the E.
Reg Tedious
2007-05-03 11:56:39 UTC
I think the t's are pronounced as for the e in Joel. Do you pronounce the e in joe. It wasn't jo-e 90 was it!
Lavender
2007-05-03 11:54:29 UTC
Remember - the pee is always silent - as in Bath!

...by the way neither 't's' are silent in the word restaurant.
Cheeks
2007-05-03 11:44:42 UTC
I wasnt aware that the t's in restaurant are silent me and everyone else i know pronounces it with t's. Maybe its our yorkshire accent...
anonymous
2007-05-03 11:43:26 UTC
Yes, very much like the strange way in which the word 'scrap' is pronounced without the 's'.
Do not trust low score answerers
2007-05-03 23:09:15 UTC
Well apart from the fact that both your examples are wrong, it's a very difficult question to answer. So I won't bother.
indranath
2007-05-03 11:57:40 UTC
Restaurant is a French word. In French it is pronounced something like "REStORAn". Here t and n are pronounced with very light touch. In case of JOEL, (O+E) is a dipthong and it is pronounced something like "oye"and Joel is prounced like Joyel (O + Y + E) is called triphone.



Please go through the following to know more about silent use of letters in English.



Use of silent E



Get and Gat(e), Fat and Fat(e), Flat & Plat(e)





When silent E occurs in an English word, it converts a vowel to its "long" equivalent. If English were spelled with the traditional Romance language vowel values of the Latin alphabet, often these vowels would be written with another letter entirely. Moreover, alternatives exist in English for most spellings that use silent E. Depending on dialect, English has anywhere from thirteen to more than twenty separate vowel sounds (both monophthongs and diphthongs). Silent E is one of the ways English spelling is able to use the Latin alphabet's five vowel characters to represent so many vowels.



Traditionally, the vowels /ei (as in bait beet bite boat beauty) are said to be the "long" counterparts of the vowels /æ (as in bat bet bit bot but) which are said to be "short". This terminology reflects the historical pronunciation and development of those vowels; as a phonetic description of their current values, it is no longer accurate. The values of the vowels these sounds are written with used to be similar to the values those letters had in French or Italian. The traditional "long vowels" also closely correspond to the letter names those vowels bear in the English alphabet, and the letter name is usually an accurate guide to the value of the vowel that is affected by silent E.



This variety of vowels is due to the effects of the Great Vowel Shift that marked the end of Middle English and the beginning of Early Modern English. The vowel shift gave current English "long vowels" values that differ markedly from the "short vowels" that they relate to in writing. Since English has a literary tradition that goes back into the Middle English period, written English continues to use Middle English writing conventions to mark distinctions that had been reordered by the chain shift of the long vowels.



When final 'e' is not silent, this generally requires some sort of indication in English spelling. This is usually done via doubling (employee: this word has employe as an obsolete spelling). When the silent e becomes a part of an inflection, its non-silent status can be indicated by a number of diacritical marks, such as a grave accent (learnèd) or a diaeresis (learnëd, Brontë). Other diacritical marks can appear in foreign words (compare résumé with nativized resume).



The sounds of the 'a' group are some of the more dialectically complex features of contemporary modern English; the sounds that can be represented in modern English by 'a' include /æ/.



The 'e' group

Silent E typically moves 'e' to /iː/. This change is generally consistent across all English dialects.





The 'i' group

For the "long vowel" represented in written English by 'i', the effect of silent E is to turn it into a diphthong / In some dialects, this diphthong is affected by the voiced or unvoiced quality of the following consonant so that it may be closer to see Canadian raising.





The 'o' group

Short 'o', in contemporary English, tends to fall in with short 'a' and to share some of the complexities of that group; depending on dialect, the written short 'o' can represent . The usual effect of silent E on written 'o' is to fix it as a long o sound. In several dialects of English, this long realized as a diphthong and in some forms of southern British English, the leading element is centralized further, yielding . All of the sounds in the previous sentence are in free variation with one another.





The 'u' group

Silent E generally turns the sound written as 'u' to its corresponding long vowel /juː/, although there are exceptions depending on dialect (see yod-dropping). Initial long 'u' as in use is almost always subject to iotacism.





Silent E and consonants

Silent E also functions as a front vowel for purposes of representing the outcome in English of palatalized sounds. For example:







Truly silent E

In some common words that historically had long vowels, silent E no longer has its usual lengthening effect: come, done. This is especially common in some words that historically had 'f' instead of 'v', such as give and love; in Old English, /f/ became /v/ when it appeared between two vowels (OE giefan, lufu), while a geminated 'ff' lost its doubling to yield /f/ in that position. This also applies to a large class of words with the adjective suffix '-ive', such as captive, that originally had '-if' in French.



Some English words vary their accented syllable based on whether they are used as nouns or as adjectives. In a few words such as minute, this may affect the operation of silent E: as an adjective, minúte has the usual value of 'u' followed by silent E, while as a noun mínute silent E does not operate. See initial-stress-derived noun for similar patterns that may give rise to exceptions.
anonymous
2007-05-03 11:47:35 UTC
think you might have a speech impediment.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...